Menu
    English

    Thinking in form: when making becomes inquiry

    Publicatie van Kenniscentrum Creating 010

    P. Troxler, C. Middelkoop,van, J.A. Schelling, C. Smits | Conferentiebijdrage | Publicatiedatum: 19 oktober 2026
    A student in a design studio asks a generative image system for twenty concepts and receives them before the first sketch is complete. A colleague in public policy uses the same system to assemble a service journey and a plausible prototype without commissioning a designer. In both cases a form has been produced. What, if anything, was learned through producing it, and what expertise is needed to judge and develop it further? Both scenes rest on a view of formgiving that design education itself has long sustained: formgiving as the final aesthetic stage of a design process, the shaping, styling, detailing, or visual refinement of an already defined concept. On that view, the generator has simply taken over the last step. The call asks what makes a designer if everybody designs. We propose that this question becomes sharper, and more uncomfortable, when posed as an epistemological question rather than an identity question: how does making produce knowledge, what kind of knowledge does it produce in a particular practice, and who can judge whether that knowledge is warranted? We argue that formgiving is an epistemic practice: shaping something in order to discover, test, and communicate what was not fully known beforehand. Its value lies neither in manual execution alone nor in the existence of a finished object. It lies in a sequence of consequential choices, encounters with resistance, interpretation, and revision. Generative AI changes that sequence, especially when forms are symbolic or visual. This makes the designer’s ability to frame, judge, and answer for a form more visible. It calls for distinctions in education and research that follow the work and its setting.

    Auteur(s) - verbonden aan Hogeschool Rotterdam

    Betrokken bij deze publicatie

    Inloggen